When I think about my husband, who died last year, I sometimes wonder, did I dream our life together? And so, I have been pondering this: Is there a difference between the memory of someone who has died and a dream?
Well, yes, there is an obvious difference. I have proof of the life that Bill and I shared – there are photos and objects and words he wrote to me. I also remain connected to his family; I trust they would vouch for our life together. There is, by contrast, no proof of a dream once we have dreamed it.
Still, physical proof notwithstanding, my life with Bill has no more substance than a dream now that he is gone.
I suppose this is true of any memory of past events. They may live on in our hearts and minds, but we can’t step back into them, can’t touch them.
And there’s this. We know memories to be unreliable. Apparently, each time we revisit a memory, it changes as we recontruct and reassemble it.
Yet, imperfect as our memories may be, they ground us and give our lives substance and meaning. I treasure memories of Bll, of my daughters as young children, of adventures and events in the past.
We are encouraged to live in the present moment, and some of us strive, with more or less success, to do so, but without our memories, we would be quite adrift, floating in an endless present, untethered to past events or future plans.
Of course, very young children live in an endless present, but this only works for them because they have caretakers to handle the details. We adults, by contrast, would live in a state of constant bafflement were we not grounded in time (as demonstrated by persons with dementia).
I do step out of time occasionally – often while writing; sometimes while playing with grandchildren. Anyone totally focused on an activity recognizes this state. It is sometimes called flow.
But the world we live in requires us to step back into time in order to think about what we’re going to have for dinner and remember what’s in the refrigerator. If we step out of time entirely, we step out of life --at least as long as we are on this plane.
I like to think that after we die, there is no time, not because everything has ended, but because we have left the dimension where time has meaning. And I like to think I will meet Bill in the great mystery, where we will dwell in the light and love of the eternal present.
For now, I will keep moving forward, curious to learn what time has in store for me, and preserving Bill's memory--along with memories of others who have been important to me, as well as I can.

Photo by Илья Мельниченко on Unsplash
The intangibleness that death imposes makes absence feel dreamlike. From a physical standpoint, though, there is a great difference. The brain works because of the connections between the neurons. For those we love, they are connected to a multitude of experiences: other people, other places, events, foods, sensations all stored in our memories.
ReplyDeleteThe light flurries of snow in the gap between winter and Spring always take me to the night Jim and I first kissed. And that is just one example out of millions.
The work of grief is to come to understand how much of the person who has died is still with us. Not just in memory, but in the intertwining of how they made us who we are, and how they still intertwine with so much of our reality.
When you ask yourself "what would Bill do in this situation?" Chances are your heart provides the answer.
Dreams evaporate. Death though does not erase the love.
-dor
Wow, Marjorie, You covered so much. Grief, memories, time, staying present while not forgetting the past. Thank you, for making me think and ponder.
ReplyDeleteD.K.
Marjorie I believe Bill agrees when I say, this is beautiful ❤️🔥
ReplyDeleteSheila
Beautiful Marjorie. Thanks for the lovely posting
ReplyDeleteKim
This is fascinating!
ReplyDeleteBeautiful, Marjorie! All so very true.
ReplyDelete❤️
ReplyDeleteThis makes me realize how close the felt sense of pleasure and pain are, especially when recalling someone beloved who was once here, embodied, and is now dreamlike and if here, in a different way. I can feel the ache of that loss and the tenderness in your beautiful provocative questions about time, Marjorie. They make me think about all the ways that love reveals itself.
ReplyDeleteIt is a wonderment and mystery about memories vs. dreams. Some dreams I really really wished were in my life, and I seem to hold many memories that did not actually happen in my current life. Was I born with them? Did I live before? Did the network of my brain invent things that seen real but are not? Thank you for letting me ponder these thoughts.
ReplyDeleteJennifer
As usual, you've covered you subject so well that I have nothing worthwhile to add. But there's certainly a lot to think about.
ReplyDelete